P&R Miscellany tries the now-familiar tactic of beating us liberals over their head with our own relativism and tolerance. P&R forgets that I'm not a relativist and I don't tolerate baloney.

P&R counters the successful backlash against South Dakota's failed anti-gay legislation by inviting us to shoe the other foot with the possibility that gay-hating Westboro Baptist Church members would demand to rent a party room from a gay entrepreneur, or that Klansmen would order catering from Harlem for a KKK wedding.

"Tolerance... should flow both ways," says P&R. The National Review correspondent he cites speaks similarly:

“Live and let live” implies a two-way relationship. Mutual respect is an attitude that, like the biblical leaven, has to be mixed in thoroughly and evenly, until the whole is leavened [Kevin D. Williamson, "Until the Whole Is Leavened," National Review Online, 2014.02.20].

P&R's and Williamson's own language grants us leave to dismiss their own argument. Their examples refer to customers who offer no two-way relationship (unlike bisexuals, who—well... um...), who do not respect the vendors with whom P&R hopes my liberal tolerance will mandate a relationship.

Gay couples don't walk into a bakery shouting, "God Hates Straights!" unless they are feeling really snippy and ironic. They won't yell at straight caterers, "Go back to Africa where you heteros belong!" That language doesn't fit the other foot.

Westboro's homophobes and the KKK seek the exclusion, damnation, and destruction of the people they don't tolerate. (Actually, I'm not convinced Westboro wants even that; they just want attention.) Gay couples just want to go about their business, then go home and give each other the business, pretty much like the rest of us.

Tolerance works, but it does not mandate the absurdity and moral surrender that P&R posits.

5 comments

Loose on Religion, Uptight on Homosexuals

ThePostSD.com alerts us to another reason we might have trouble convincing some young people to stick around on the prairie. The Daily Beast spent Martin Luther King Day calculating how tolerant the states of the Union are and found South Dakota ranks 39th. The analysis considers hate crime laws and reported incidents, discrimination complaints, public support for and laws covering same-sex marriage, and religious tolerance.

It is worth noting that if you seek more tolerant climes, you don't have to travel far. Minnesota turns up the nice and ranks 7th; Iowa ranks 12th. Drive a little farther, and you'll find the most tolerant state of the Union, Wisconsin. Liberal bastions New York and Massachusetts are only 17th and 18th, respectively.

If heading east isn't your thing, Montana is your next best bet, ranking 21st for tolerance (which is funny, because Mr. Kurtz doesn't always sound that tolerant when Mr. Ellis is around). Otherwise, in our region, you'd better keep your diversity to yourself: North Dakota ranks 42nd, Nebraska ranks 47th (dragged down by intolerance for wearing any colors other than Cornhusker Red), and Wyoming ranks 50th.

Now I'll confess to my own disagreement with this analysis, at least on religious tolerance. This analysis quantifies religious tolerance as the percentage of folks who believe "many religions lead to eternal life." South Dakota actually ranks quite high on this metric: 79%... though I have to wonder if a fair number of South Dakotans hear the question and think, "Many religions? Oh, ya, sure, Lutherans, Methodists, Baptists, even those Catholics can get to heaven." I'd be interested in recalibrating that measurement by asking folks their opinion about electing an atheist or a Muslim governor or blessing their children's marrying folks of different faiths or no faith.

Besides, "eternal life" seems a rather particular theological point on which to grade the broader question of religious tolerance. There's enough old-school absolutism in my atheist soul ("soul"?) to accept that tolerance means holding your nose and letting me go about my business, not taking a deep whiff and exclaiming, "Boy, you smell sweet!" I'm satisfied with the tolerance of a good Christian who holds to fundamental doctrinal differences (like the debatable proposition that Jesus is the only path to eternal life, or that there is such a thing) but still supports a civil society where Muslims, Buddhists, and even infidels like me have the same rights to participate in economic, political and social life.

But religious tolerance isn't where South Dakota needs work. Our gay rights score stinks. It's one thing to think your neighbors are on a fast track away from eternal life. It's another to extend that belief into interference with the exercise of homosexual citizens' rights to live and love as they see fit and obtain legal and financial protection (e.g., spousal insurance benefits) for their loved ones. Just as my chosen non-religion can withstand folks down the road exercising their rights with regular Hallelujahs, my heterosexual marriage should be able to withstand some of my male neighbors' choosing to be cohabiting soulmates and even their getting legal status and insurance as a married couple. That's the practical tolerance South Dakota needs to work on.

5 comments

Support Your Local Blogger!

  • Click the Tip Jar to send your donation to the Madville Times via PayPal, and support local alternative news and commentary!

South Dakota Political Blogs

Greater SD Blogosphere

SD Mostly Political Mix

Greater SD Blogosphere

  • Idle Hands Dep't
    Geography Div (Gimme Shelter subsection): I think we knew this already (save one orange-hued individual who has no idea whatsoever).…
    2020.08.10

  • SleuthSayers
    The Writer Diaries: Joseph Pittmanintroducing… Joseph Pittman is a friend from about the time we opened bookstore in Austin, called Mysteries and More. I was writing a column for Mystery Scene magazine called Southwest S…
    2020.08.09

  • Native Hope Blog
    July Hope Report: July brought sounds of happiness and sights of joy for our team, volunteers, and communities. We spent the past 18 weeks making new friendships and establishing valuable bonds—bonds that will extend w…
    2020.08.09

  • Rant-a-Bit by Scott Hudson
    The Ledge #439: New Releases (Pt. 1): It's another super-busy month of new music. In fact, once again the new release series has to be split into a two-part extravaganza.Part one features previews of new records by Ledge favorites su…
    2020.08.07

  • Mark Haugen
    Bears, ballots and nut-burgers: I'm not sure why, but I find this story and the response to it very funny: Animal rights group offers $5,000 reward for information on who put 'Trump 2020' sticker on a bearBlack bears…
    2020.08.04

  • The Poetry of Barry G. Wick
    Bat Shit: Bat ShitI'm certain this isn't some crazy notionof why the world has used this phraseto denote one kind of sanityLet us reviewInsanityInsaneCrazyBizarreOddLoonyOff the rockerLost the marbles…
    2020.08.03

  • Notes from a Western Life
    Library Secrets: The July/August issue of Poets & Writers, one of the best resources for writers I know, features an intriguing article, “Secrets Hidden in the Stacks” that is going to send me prowling through my…
    2020.07.06

  • OMG Center » Blog
    Naming the Nine, and Calling a Thing What It Is: REPENT. Christians (Lutherans perhaps especially) like to talk all the time about forgiveness. We love love love forgiveness. And as an extra bonus, we can even talk about forgiveness in polite compan…
    2020.06.17

  • Minister to the Heart
    There is no going back (a reflection): After years of self reflection in the world of academia that earned me two master’s degrees and sitting in countless chairs at multiple therapists office, I understand why I feel comfortable in crisis…
    2020.06.11

  • Teaching and Inspiring Math Educators (TIME)
    Silent No More: I have watched the events of the last week unfold and I have been silent; as a white privileged female what can I possibly say? I will never understand what BIPOC endure on a daily basis. However, I a…
    2020.06.01

Madville Monthly

Meta